Disney’s live-action “Beauty and the Beast” became available on Netflix last week. After re-watching the movie, I was reminded of a brilliant Buzzfeed article called “12 Questions Disney Forgot To Answer About ‘Beauty and the Beast.’” The article points out some major plot holes in the original animated film. The live-action film fills most of these…it’s almost as if Disney went through this exact list and answered all twelve questions. So, let’s see how they addressed them
1. If Beast is royal, where are the king and queen?
Image Source
They’re dead. According to the live-action, the Beast/prince’s mother died when he was a boy. And from the way they talk about his father, it’s safe to assume that he’s passed.
2. Who the heck punishes a child for not letting a stranger into the house? If the castle has been cursed for 10 years, and the curse cannot be broken once the Beast has turned 21, he would’ve been 11 when the old woman came to his door. Did the enchantress really punish a child for obeying the rules of stranger danger?
Image Source
Disney completely gets rid of the age-specific time limit in the live-action, or any reference as to how long the castle has been cursed for. In the prologue, we see the prince get cursed as an adult. Lumiere sings “too long we’ve been rusting” instead of the original “ten years we’ve been rusting.” We only know that the curse cannot be reversed once the last petal falls.
3. Why did Belle let Gaston into her home when she knew he was trying to pursue her?
Image Source
This one is simple. In the live-action, she doesn’t. That whole creepy scene is avoided. Phew.
4. Who are all of the objects without faces? Are they self-aware?
Image Source
Not all of the objects in the castle used to be servants. Some of them are just enchanted. Belle is informed of this in the live-action when she asks a hairbrush for its name, and Cogsworth laughs and says, “That is a hairbrush.” Oh. Of course.
5. How is there a portrait of the prince as an adult if he was only 11 years old when he was cursed?
Image Source
Disney explains this by having the prince be an adult when he is cursed. (See #2)
6. What would’ve happened if Belle would have touched the rose? Why was the Beast so freaked out?
Image Source
Since the curse is permanent when the last petal falls, and the Beast has no idea when that’s going to be in the live-action, he would be afraid of anything that could hurt the rose or make the petals fall faster.
7. How did Belle get the Beast onto her horse? That guy is heavy.
Image Source
In the live-action, Belle asks the Beast to stand so she can help him get back to the castle. Bam. Why couldn’t have Disney done that the first time?
8. How does Chip exist? He’s way younger than ten. Did Mrs. Potts give birth as a teapot?
Image Source
In the prologue, you see Chip’s back for a few seconds. So, he was a little boy when the curse happened.
9. How the heck did Belle not figure out that the Beast was a prince, or that there was any sort of curse?
Image Source
The live-action throws keeping the curse a secret out the window. The enchanted objects tell Belle about the curse right before “Something There,” which is pretty early in her stay at the castle. They don’t tell her how to break the curse, though. Who would want that kind of pressure, anyway? You have to love this guy, or we’re all going to die.
10. Whose clothes are they wearing?
Image Source
In the live action, Madame Garderobe (the wardrobe), makes clothes.
11. Why didn’t Belle say she’d be back when the Beast let her go help her father?
Image Source
She didn’t know she would be back. The only reason she comes back is because Gaston decides to attack the castle, and she goes to warn the Beast.
12. How did the villagers not know there was a cursed prince within walking distance? Did they completely forget about the heir to the throne?
Image Source
Yes, they did. According to the live-action, the enchantress wiped all of their memories.
What do you think of the live action? Leave your opinions in comments!
Title Photo Source